Too much money guarantees failure
On Friday the 13th the FAA's systems went down and flights stopped cold, and within a day the ask was $50 billion. Christopher explains why too much money guarantees failure, and why the right question is the simplest design that makes this outage impossible.
Transcript
Want to guarantee a project fails? Give it too much money. Here's what I believe. Efficiency is the soul of elegant design. You measure a design by how simple it is. The simpler, the better. Complexity isn't sophistication. It's the problem. And money is how complexity gets in the door. Big budgets don't buy simple. They buy more of everything. On Friday the 13th the FAA's systems went down and flights stopped cold. Within a day the ask was fifty billion dollars. Wrong question. The right one is: what's the simplest design that makes this outage impossible? Look at what they're running now. The Secretary himself says some of those routers were bought in 2001 and obsolete by 2006. Some of the core systems are older than that. Patch on patch, layer on layer. Nobody simplified. They just kept stacking. There's a reason. The FAA's big telecom contract keeps getting extended without anybody else getting a shot at it. Think about what that rewards. Make it simpler, and next year's contract gets smaller. So complexity becomes the product. Boeing and Artemis, same movie. When the contract is the goal, success is optional. We've seen this before. Healthcare.gov cost nearly a billion dollars,
and the budget became the spec. Every requirement made the cut, and the thing barely worked. Education runs the same loop. More programs, more layers, results stay flat, so the answer is... more spending. Meanwhile, the private sector's spent forty years simplifying. ATMs. UPC scanners. Weekend inventory counts. Whole server rooms, gone to the cloud. Fill out the FedEx form right, and your package shows up. Amazon is a crazy efficient system, and it delivers a ton of value. Now think about the DMV. Expensive. Slow. Long lines. An experience nobody would pick if they had a choice. In my entire 30-plus-year career, the two things I've never found together are an inefficient system and a delighted customer. Then there's SpaceX. Starship is chasing launch costs around one percent of what they used to be. Not by spending more. By simplifying. Elon's line is "the best part is no part." Delete the part. Delete the step. Question every requirement. What's left is only what the design actually needs. Inefficiency isn't a side effect. It's how you measure the failure. So before anyone writes a fifty billion dollar check, ask for the simplest design that works. Fund that. Nothing more. Simple isn't the cheap version.
It's the finished one.